The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

New news and release discussion.
QuiescentWonder
User avatar
Donator
Posts: 2365
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2008 10:22 am

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by QuiescentWonder »

motherboardlove wrote:
kurogin wrote:
J.Byrne wrote:Shame to see the site go, wonder when Mininova will follow.
When the owners lose a giant lawsuit.
But Mininova has a copyright policy, and actually takes down torrents when I sent them a cease and desist letter.
So does isoHunt but they got sued anyway.

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

Cause maybe they havent removed the torrent yet A LOT of torrents are still there... Ive never seen a ISOHUNT torrent get removed
See my profile for my website link.

pkubaj
User avatar
FTP Access
Posts: 638
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2008 6:05 pm

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by pkubaj »

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-10289985-93.html
KaZaa too Internet gets cleared from piracy

OG
User avatar
FTP Access
Posts: 628
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2008 3:45 am
Location: UK

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by OG »

motherboardlove wrote:Cause maybe they havent removed the torrent yet A LOT of torrents are still there... Ive never seen a ISOHUNT torrent get removed
I have, lots.

In isoHunt's case the simple fact is that the MPAA (rather the copyright holders they represent) almost never bothered to send takedown requests, and couldn't care less if isoHunt had a copyright policy. They wanted blood so they sued. When it comes to the **AA's there really is no reasoning.

James
User avatar
Staff
Posts: 2029
Joined: Thu Oct 11, 2007 9:13 pm
Location: United States

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by James »

Here is a little tip. Piracy can never be extinguished. Even if, every piracy site is tooken down, Piracy can be committed as easily as this:


You own a copy of Office 2007.
Your pal wants it, but cant afford it.
You burn him a copy and go to a serial site and get a serial
You give him the copy/serial

Piracy. You just gave away a free copy of a commercial product.
James *~*~* BA Moderator | Alternate History writer

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

James wrote:Here is a little tip. Piracy can never be extinguished. Even if, every piracy site is tooken down, Piracy can be committed as easily as this:


You own a copy of Office 2007.
Your pal wants it, but cant afford it.
You burn him a copy and go to a serial site and get a serial
You give him the copy/serial

Piracy. You just gave away a free copy of a commercial product.
A serial site IS a piracy site, IMO
See my profile for my website link.

Kenneth
Donator
Posts: 2407
Joined: Sun May 13, 2007 12:42 am

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by Kenneth »

Give the guy your serial number/product key.

OG
User avatar
FTP Access
Posts: 628
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2008 3:45 am
Location: UK

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by OG »

motherboardlove wrote:
A serial site IS a piracy site, IMO

Debatable. I'd say not. If I say 1234-abc-5678, and that just happens to unlock some random piece of software, then I just committed piracy, that is the folly in your argument. From what I know, you cannot copyright a number or any other alphanumeric string, you can have one as a registered trademark, but not copyrighted. If I remember correctly this was/is also the case for encryption keys, like those used to crack BluRay which every man and his dog had for a forum sig at one time because there was nothing illegal about displaying a string of numbers or letters. At the very most, a serial would be nothing more than trademark infringement, and only if it has been registered as a trademark. It is not copyright infringement, and it is not piracy no matter your opinon. On the other hand, using it to circumvent copy protection or to activate a product you didnt pay for is illegal, but that's down to the individual (and the applicable laws in their country).

J.Byrne
Donator
Posts: 2045
Joined: Sat May 24, 2008 10:05 am

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by J.Byrne »

1: A site offering serials, provided these serials are not stolen, and not offering cracks of any sort, has not commited piracy.
2: As you said, thats your opinion (IMO), as your opinion it should be respected. If you had said it was a fact, you'd be wrong.

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

J.Byrne wrote: 1: A site offering serials, provided these serials are not stolen, and not offering cracks of any sort, has not commited piracy.
Depends on what you define piracy as. I define piracy as violation of the End User License Agreement, and distribution of product key and/or serials and/or activation keys and/or other stuff, is clearly in violation of that.
J.Byrne wrote: 2: As you said, thats your opinion (IMO), as your opinion it should be respected. If you had said it was a fact, you'd be wrong.
Right... It just depends on how you define piracy.
See my profile for my website link.

hounsell

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by hounsell »

motherboardlove wrote:Depends on what you define piracy as. I define piracy as violation of the End User License Agreement, and distribution of product key and/or serials and/or activation keys and/or other stuff, is clearly in violation of that.
That's not how the law defines 'Piracy'. 'Piracy' is taken to mean the infringement of copyright law. The key is not copyrighted, the product is. That's why Microsoft, and every other company, have EULAs.

hougtimo
FTP Access
Posts: 632
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 2:42 pm
Location: c:\tmp\*
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by hougtimo »

motherboardlove wrote:
kurogin wrote:
J.Byrne wrote:Shame to see the site go, wonder when Mininova will follow.
When the owners lose a giant lawsuit.
But Mininova has a copyright policy, and actually takes down torrents when I sent them a cease and desist letter.
They were distributing your software were they?

Derf
User avatar
Donator
Posts: 3937
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2008 8:09 pm
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by Derf »

motherboardlove wrote:Cause maybe they havent removed the torrent yet A LOT of torrents are still there... Ive never seen a ISOHUNT torrent get removed
If you hate piracy so much, why are you looking up and watching torrents containing copyrighted content on ISOHunt in the first place? Why would you even think of doing that, as an upstanding individual? :\
motherboardlove wrote:But Mininova has a copyright policy, and actually takes down torrents when I sent them a cease and desist letter.
Did you hold the copyright to the content you requested be removed?

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

Derf wrote:
motherboardlove wrote:Cause maybe they havent removed the torrent yet A LOT of torrents are still there... Ive never seen a ISOHUNT torrent get removed
If you hate piracy so much, why are you looking up and watching torrents containing copyrighted content on ISOHunt in the first place? Why would you even think of doing that, as an upstanding individual? :\
There ARE betas out there, and theres also legal torrents. Is a torrent of Ubuntu illegal? I think not.

I goto ISOhunt for 2 reasons: to check to see if torrents of MY software are out there (and to take them down), and to get legal BT goods (Ubuntu, OpenOffice, etc)

ISOHunt decides to wait about 1 and a half months before removing it, when I said that they should remove in 2 WEEKS or face legal action. Obviously, ISOhunt does not give a damn about removeing the torrents.
motherboardlove wrote:But Mininova has a copyright policy, and actually takes down torrents when I sent them a cease and desist letter.
Did you hold the copyright to the content you requested be removed?[/quote]

Yes
See my profile for my website link.

OG
User avatar
FTP Access
Posts: 628
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2008 3:45 am
Location: UK

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by OG »

If under the terms of isoHunt's copyright policy, a copyright holder requests takedown of a torrent, and they follow a procedure set out to determine who does and who does not have a legitimate claim for removal, then once that person has verified to be in a position to make such a request and the content verified to be theirs (not misnamed for example), the torrent will be removed. If isoHunt didn't give a damn about removing torrents, they wouldn't have a policy of removal. More than likely, if you had trouble getting something removed, you either did not follow the instructions as to what was needed to verify your rights as a the holder, or you made yourself look like an ass by trying to be bullish, which would only get your request ignored.

I have seen torrents removed THE VERY SAME DAY, where there was no question of the person being the rights holder, and they approached the subject directly and maturely. Those who don't get told in no uncertain terms to [censored] off.

hougtimo
FTP Access
Posts: 632
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 2:42 pm
Location: c:\tmp\*
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by hougtimo »

And this software of your, Motherboardlove, was?

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

OG wrote:If under the terms of isoHunt's copyright policy, a copyright holder requests takedown of a torrent, and they follow a procedure set out to determine who does and who does not have a legitimate claim for removal, then once that person has verified to be in a position to make such a request and the content verified to be theirs (not misnamed for example), the torrent will be removed. If isoHunt didn't give a damn about removing torrents, they wouldn't have a policy of removal. More than likely, if you had trouble getting something removed, you either did not follow the instructions as to what was needed to verify your rights as a the holder, or you made yourself look like an ass by trying to be bullish, which would only get your request ignored.

I have seen torrents removed THE VERY SAME DAY, where there was no question of the person being the rights holder, and they approached the subject directly and maturely. Those who don't get told in no uncertain terms to [censored] off.
I dont have to follow their procedure. I just take legal action if its not removed in 2 weeks of the C&D. I dont need to follow their removal procedure. They have to follow mine - becuase I am the IP Holder, and I CAN take legal action.
hougtimo wrote:And this software of your, Motherboardlove, was?
It was custom software, leaked by an employee.
See my profile for my website link.

OG
User avatar
FTP Access
Posts: 628
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2008 3:45 am
Location: UK

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by OG »

No, you do have to follow their procedure. You see isoHunt is not based in the US, therefor they do not have any legal obligation to adhere to DMCA or any takedown requests, yet they do purely as a courtesy to rights holders, provided the copyright holder follows said procedure. Given your apparent attitude I do not find it unusual that you seem to have problems with them. Your attitude towards intellectual property is precisely the reason so many people go out of their way to pirate, simply to show people like you how little value your idea of intellectual property has in reality. You might feel you have rights, and the laws in your country might agree with that, but that is not true everywhere, where frankly your rights don't mean jack squat and no one has any obligation towards you what so ever.

hougtimo
FTP Access
Posts: 632
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 2:42 pm
Location: c:\tmp\*
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by hougtimo »

Too add to OC's post; No judge would look kindly on your case if you rushed it to court without giving appropriate notice & time for rectification.

motherboardlove
Donator
Posts: 1237
Joined: Sat Oct 04, 2008 5:43 pm
Location: Milky Way Galaxy
Contact:

Re: The Pirate Bay no more - bought out by Global Gaming Factory

Post by motherboardlove »

hougtimo wrote:Too add to OC's post; No judge would look kindly on your case if you rushed it to court without giving appropriate notice & time for rectification.
I did give appropriate time. I gave 2 WEEKS. Is 2 weeks not enough to hit the simple button "Delete"?

@OC

I can get rid of the torrent in a creative way - I can take legal action of the users of that torrent - IE I add the torrent to uTorrent, write down their IP and send C&Ds.

Will a moderator or administrator lock this topic, I think its becoming a flame war...
See my profile for my website link.

Locked